monitoring/VXLAN_DISCOVERY_SUCCESS.md

@@ -0,0 +1,251 @@
+# VXLAN Telemetry Discovery - SUCCESS! 🎉
+
+## What We Discovered
+
+The path `/interfaces/interface[name=Vxlan1]` **WORKS** and returns **rich VXLAN data** including Arista's `arista-exp-eos-vxlan` augmentation!
+
+### Test Command
+
+```bash
+gnmic -a 172.16.0.25:6030 -u admin -p admin --insecure \
+  get --path /interfaces/interface[name=Vxlan1]
+```
+
+### Response Structure
+
+```json
+{
+  "interfaces/interface": {
+    "arista-exp-eos-vxlan:arista-vxlan": {
+      "config": {
+        "src-ip-intf": "Loopback1",
+        "udp-port": 4789,
+        "mac-learn-mode": "LEARN_FROM_ANY",
+        ...
+      },
+      "state": {
+        "src-ip-intf": "Loopback1",
+        "udp-port": 4789,
+        ...
+      },
+      "vlan-to-vnis": {
+        "vlan-to-vni": [
+          {
+            "vlan": 40,
+            "vni": 110040,
+            "state": {...},
+            "config": {...}
+          }
+        ]
+      }
+    },
+    "openconfig-interfaces:config": {...},
+    "openconfig-interfaces:state": {...}
+  }
+}
+```
+
+## VXLAN Metrics Available
+
+### 1. VNI-to-VLAN Mappings
+
+From `arista-vxlan.vlan-to-vnis.vlan-to-vni[]`:
+
+```prometheus
+# Metrics will be like:
+gnmic_vxlan_interfaces_interface_arista_vxlan_vlan_to_vnis_vlan_to_vni_state_vlan{source="leaf1"}
+gnmic_vxlan_interfaces_interface_arista_vxlan_vlan_to_vnis_vlan_to_vni_state_vni{source="leaf1"}
+```
+
+**Use Case**: Know which VLANs are mapped to which VNIs on each VTEP
+
+### 2. VXLAN Source Interface
+
+From `arista-vxlan.state.src-ip-intf`:
+
+```prometheus
+gnmic_vxlan_interfaces_interface_arista_vxlan_state_src_ip_intf{source="leaf1"} = "Loopback1"
+```
+
+**Use Case**: Verify correct loopback is used for VTEP source
+
+### 3. VXLAN UDP Port
+
+From `arista-vxlan.state.udp-port`:
+
+```prometheus
+gnmic_vxlan_interfaces_interface_arista_vxlan_state_udp_port{source="leaf1"} = 4789
+```
+
+**Use Case**: Verify standard VXLAN port configuration
+
+### 4. MAC Learning Mode
+
+From `arista-vxlan.state.mac-learn-mode`:
+
+```prometheus
+gnmic_vxlan_interfaces_interface_arista_vxlan_state_mac_learn_mode{source="leaf1"} = "LEARN_FROM_ANY"
+```
+
+**Use Case**: Verify MAC learning configuration
+
+### 5. MLAG Configuration
+
+From `arista-vxlan.state.mlag-shared-router-mac-config`:
+
+```prometheus
+gnmic_vxlan_interfaces_interface_arista_vxlan_state_mlag_shared_router_mac_config{source="leaf1"}
+```
+
+**Use Case**: MLAG-specific VXLAN settings
+
+## Updated gnmic Configuration
+
+The updated `gnmic.yaml` now includes:
+
+```yaml
+subscriptions:
+  vxlan:
+    paths:
+      - /interfaces/interface[name=Vxlan1]
+    mode: stream
+    stream-mode: on_change  # Config changes are infrequent
+    encoding: json_ietf
+```
+
+**Key points:**
+- Uses `on_change` streaming (VNI mappings don't change often)
+- Only subscribed on **leaf switches** (spines don't have VXLAN)
+- Captures full Arista VXLAN augmentation
+
+## Grafana Dashboard Queries
+
+### VNI Count per VTEP
+
+```promql
+# Count active VNIs per leaf
+count by (source, vtep) (
+  gnmic_vxlan_interfaces_interface_arista_vxlan_vlan_to_vnis_vlan_to_vni_state_vni
+)
+```
+
+### VNI-to-VLAN Mapping Table
+
+Create a table visualization with:
+
+```promql
+# Show VNI -> VLAN mappings
+gnmic_vxlan_interfaces_interface_arista_vxlan_vlan_to_vnis_vlan_to_vni_state_vni
+```
+
+Format columns:
+- `source` = Device name
+- `vlan` = VLAN ID
+- `Value` = VNI number
+
+### VXLAN Configuration Check
+
+```promql
+# Check if all leaves use Loopback1
+gnmic_vxlan_interfaces_interface_arista_vxlan_state_src_ip_intf
+
+# Check if all use standard UDP port 4789
+gnmic_vxlan_interfaces_interface_arista_vxlan_state_udp_port
+```
+
+### Combined VXLAN Health Dashboard
+
+Combine with existing metrics:
+
+```promql
+# VXLAN tunnel bandwidth
+rate(gnmic_interfaces_interface_state_counters_out_octets{interface_name="Vxlan1"}[1m]) * 8
+
+# VXLAN tunnel errors
+rate(gnmic_interfaces_interface_state_counters_in_errors{interface_name="Vxlan1"}[5m])
+
+# VXLAN interface status
+gnmic_interfaces_interface_state_oper_status{interface_name="Vxlan1"}
+
+# VNI count
+count by (source) (gnmic_vxlan_interfaces_interface_arista_vxlan_vlan_to_vnis_vlan_to_vni_state_vni)
+
+# EVPN neighbor count (VTEP reachability)
+count by (source) (gnmic_bgp_neighbors_neighbor_state_session_state{afi_safi_name="L2VPN_EVPN"} == 6)
+```
+
+## Benefits Over Previous Approach
+
+### Before (Without VXLAN Subscription)
+- ✅ Vxlan1 interface traffic
+- ✅ BGP EVPN neighbors
+- ❌ No VNI-to-VLAN visibility
+- ❌ No VXLAN config verification
+
+### Now (With VXLAN Subscription)
+- ✅ Vxlan1 interface traffic
+- ✅ BGP EVPN neighbors
+- ✅ **VNI-to-VLAN mappings**
+- ✅ **VXLAN source interface**
+- ✅ **UDP port configuration**
+- ✅ **MAC learning mode**
+- ✅ **MLAG VXLAN settings**
+
+## Deployment
+
+```bash
+cd monitoring
+docker-compose restart gnmic
+
+# Verify VXLAN subscription is working
+docker logs gnmic | grep vxlan
+
+# Check metrics
+curl http://localhost:9804/metrics | grep vxlan | head -20
+
+# Expected metrics:
+# gnmic_vxlan_interfaces_interface_arista_vxlan_state_src_ip_intf{...}
+# gnmic_vxlan_interfaces_interface_arista_vxlan_state_udp_port{...}
+# gnmic_vxlan_interfaces_interface_arista_vxlan_vlan_to_vnis_vlan_to_vni_state_vni{...}
+# gnmic_vxlan_interfaces_interface_arista_vxlan_vlan_to_vnis_vlan_to_vni_state_vlan{...}
+```
+
+## Why This Works
+
+1. **Arista augments OpenConfig** - `arista-exp-eos-vxlan` adds VXLAN-specific data to the standard interface model
+2. **Vxlan1 is a real interface** - It's in the standard `/interfaces/interface` tree
+3. **OpenConfig + native data** - We get both OpenConfig state AND Arista-specific VXLAN config
+
+This is the **best of both worlds** - standard OpenConfig paths with vendor-specific augmentations!
+
+## What About Other Native Paths?
+
+The paths we tested that **didn't work**:
+- ❌ `/Sysdb/bridging/vxlan/status` - Requires `provider eos-native`
+- ❌ `/Smash/bridging/vxlan` - Not exposed via gNMI
+
+These require additional configuration on the switches:
+
+```
+management api gnmi
+   transport grpc default
+      provider eos-native
+```
+
+**But we don't need them!** The Vxlan1 interface path gives us everything we need.
+
+## Summary
+
+🎉 **Success!** We discovered that:
+1. `/interfaces/interface[name=Vxlan1]` works perfectly
+2. Returns rich VXLAN data via Arista augmentations
+3. Includes VNI-to-VLAN mappings, source interface, and config
+4. No need for native `eos-native` provider paths
+
+Your monitoring stack now has **complete VXLAN visibility** including:
+- VXLAN tunnel traffic (already had)
+- VTEP reachability via BGP EVPN (already had)
+- **VNI-to-VLAN mappings (NEW!)**
+- **VXLAN configuration verification (NEW!)**
+
+**Deploy with confidence!** 🚀